Category: Uncategorized

THE TAX WORKING GROUP AND CAPITAL GAINS TAX IN NEW ZEALAND — A MISSED OPPORTUNITY?

Abstract

There has been much debate in New Zealand concerning the need for a separate and comprehensive capital gains tax (‘CGT’), especially after the appointment of the Tax Working Group (‘TWG’) in 2017. The arguments for a CGT include equity, base broadening, certainty, additional tax revenues and remedying the housing affordability crisis. On the other hand, counter-arguments such as tax complexity (in the design of the CGT), overstatement of projected tax revenues, and high tax compliance and administrative costs have been raised by opponents of the tax. The TWG identified three socio-economic challenges facing New Zealand (among others) — housing affordability, income/wealth inequality and fiscal sustainability — all of which it is argued have a link to the tax system. Ultimately, for political reasons the government decided not to pursue the TWG’s recommendation for a CGT. This paper considers whether this is a lost opportunity to address these three challenges.

DOWNLOAD THE ARTICLE

WOMEN AND THE TAX WORKING GROUP

Abstract

The impact of the tax system on women and men is not the same. Women earn less than men, have lower levels of savings, and derive more of their income from wages than wealth. This means that progressivity is particularly important for women, and the taxation (or non-taxation) of savings and capital is particularly relevant to men.

To provide a basis for discussion of the way in which the New Zealand government’s Tax Working Group (‘TWG’) was invited to consider the issue of gender, and how the recommendations in its final report would impact women, this article provides an introduction to the differences between men’s and women’s experiences of the tax system. These include the relationship of the tax system with the transfer system, and the gendered difference in treatment for non-compliance in each system.

This article examines the recommendations in the TWG’s final report and explains how gender was reflected. It also critically examines the background paper, ‘Taxation and Gender’, that was provided to the TWG. The paper offered just one substantive point for discussion: ‘Does the Group agree with the Secretariat’s overall judgement that childcare costs should not be deductible?’ The limitations of this focus are discussed. This article suggests that the restricted view of gender and tax in the background paper reflects a broader lack of understanding of gender issues across the New Zealand public sector. It reflects on how this situation came about and considers how it might change.

DOWNLOAD THE ARTICLE

THE ENVIRONMENT IS NOT AN EXTERNALITY: THE CIRCULAR ECONOMY AND THE TAX WORKING GROUP

Abstract

The final report of New Zealand’s Tax Working Group (‘TWG’) is unusual for this type of inquiry. Rather than restricting its consideration to equity, efficiency and other usual tax criteria in the context of the existing economy, the TWG final report signalled aspirations for a paradigmatic shift in the way the economy is constituted and functions. As well as seeking to incorporate Te Ao Māori (a Māori worldview) and Treasury’s Living Standards Framework, the TWG embraced the radical environmentalism of the circular economy model. As the 2030 achievement target for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (‘SDGs’) draws closer, it is increasingly pertinent for policy advisors to ensure their proposals and recommendations align with the SDG ethos. Tax policy is no exception, and the TWG’s explicit consideration of sustainability, wellbeing and the circular economy may suggest an attempt to take New Zealand’s commitment to the SDGs seriously. However, despite its espousal of these features, the TWG’s recommendations for the greening of taxation were modest.

This article considers what the key features of a tax system for a circular economy might be, and assesses the TWG’s recommendations against that model. Particular attention is paid to the New Zealand context, including an economy that is currently greatly dependent on the export of primary products, notably dairy.

DOWNLOAD THE ARTICLE